Mighty Audit Monday: Suffolk Comptroller Recovers $1.7 Million


“Auditing the County’s self-insured employee medical health plan has been a priority of mine since becoming County Comptroller in 2015,” said Suffolk County Comptroller John M. Kennedy, Jr. | Facebook-John M. Kennedy Jr. | Anthem

According to Suffolk County Comptroller John M. Kennedy, Jr.’s office, the longtime local representative recently oversaw a successful audit of overpaid medical sentences. 

Comptroller Kennedy settled yet another audit with Anthem BlueCross BlueShield that revealed a massive billing error. The former administrator of hospital benefits for the County’s self-insured employee medical health plan was paying the County $1,688,138. This plan covers 45,000 active or former employees or dependents. 

Kennedy and Company deployed the Segal Group to perform the medical claims audit. The audit centered on January 1st through December 31st, 2022.

Says Kennedy’s Office: Anthem repeatedly undercharged members for copayments, thereby overcharging the County for benefits assigned. Instances of duplicate claims were also detected, in addition to overpaid plan benefit limits for acupuncture, chiropractor and physical therapy services. 

Mistakes revolved around the process of coordinating benefits with medicare claims were found to have been a systemic issue above all else.

“Auditing the County’s self-insured employee medical health plan has  been a priority of mine since becoming County Comptroller in 2015,” said Kennedy. “As a result of these audits, my  administration has recouped over $10 million in misspent medical costs for the taxpayers of Suffolk  County.”

The County ended its administrative service agreement and 19-year partnership with Anthem at the conclusion of last year, choosing to go into contract with Aetna moving forward.

Organizations Included in this History


Daily Feed

Education

Stony Brook students blend fitness and ecology in 3K EcoWalk

Stony Brook University students participated in the "Running Wild 3K EcoWalk," a new Earthstock event conducted on April 21 at the Ashley Schiff Preserve.


Sports

World Series Odds Change After the Trade Deadline

The Major League Baseball trade deadline is one of the most anticipated events on the sports calendar. Fans from every team hope their team gets the players they need for that big playoff push, or they are on the edge of their seat to read what top prospect will be coming back for their traded asset.


Opinion

SOUTH SHORE PRESS EXCLUSIVE: George Santos, My Life Behind Bars

July 25, 2025, at precisely 2:07 p.m., my world changed in a way I never could’ve imagined. That was the moment I walked through the gates of the Federal Correctional Institution Flatiron Satellite Camp in New Jersey.