Rocky Point Horror: A Killer Still at Large


Suffolk PD Chief of Detectives Darrel Simmons (R) provides an update on the search for at-large homicide suspect Matthew Zoll (L). | Suffolk County Police Department

Members of the Suffolk County Police gathered for a press conference earlier on Wednesday to provide an update regarding the case of 23-year-old Matthew Zoll—the Rocky Point man who stabbed his father to death earlier this month.

Police reports say Joseph Zoll, 61, was discovered at his 30 Quail Road home at approximately 1:25 a.m. on Saturday, Nov. 9th by a Seventh Precinct officer who was responding to a 9-1-1 call.

Joseph Zoll was able to dial for emergency assistance before succumbing to his wounds. He was transported to Stony Brook University Hospital, where he was pronounced dead on arrival shortly thereafter.

Meanwhile, a week-and-a-half later, Matthew is still on the loose.

At the Nov. 20th press conference, Darrel Simmons, the Suffolk County Police Department’s Chief of Detectives, confirmed that Zoll is 6’1'', 150 lbs., has brown hair and brown eyes, and a visible scar under his left eye.

“He fled that scene in a Black GMC Yukon, which we later discovered about 5 hours later,” said Simmons. “It was crashed at the intersection of 25A and William Floyd Parkway.”

Today, the search marches on.

“We’ve searched over 1,600 acres of land in the Shoreham area,” said Simmons, adding that they are even completing surveys of certain areas that were already checked “just to make sure.”

Police ask that anyone with knowledge of Matthew Zoll’s whereabouts—or additional information pertinent to this investigation—immediately contact 9-1-1, the Homicide Squad at (631) 852-6392, or Crime Stoppers at (800) 220-8477.

As far as safety is concerned, Chief Simmons assures the greater community that this was an isolated, targeted incident involving family members. Nonetheless, he urges residents to maintain normal precautions.

“Lock your doors,” he requests. “Lock your car doors, and the doors to your home. Don’t make it easy for someone to get in.”

Daily Feed

Sports

Smithtown's Marcus Wertheim Leads Team Australia

Former Smithtown lacrosse standout Marcus Wertheim is dominating on the world stage. The Smithtown alumnus, who currently attends Brown University, led all players at the Super Sixes tournament, delivering an elite performance against international competition.


Sports

Sachem's Coach Mercurio Elected to Lacrosse Board

Congratulations to Sachem Athletic Hall of Famer Rick Mercurio, who was elected to the World Lacrosse Board of Directors during the organization’s 2025 General Assembly. Mercurio fills one of two open Strategic Director positions, marking another significant milestone in his distinguished career in the sport.


Sports

LaFontaine Heads to the Isles Hall

Pat LaFontaine’s plaque has officially been added to the Islanders Hall of Fame wall, placing him among some of the most legendary figures in franchise history. The former star forward was inducted into the Ring of Honor at UBS Arena, becoming the 17th member to receive the prestigious distinction.