Retiree alleges coin dealers orchestrated multi-million dollar fraud scheme


Margo Brodie, Chief Judge with the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of New York | Administrative Office of the United States Courts | Wikipedia Commons

An 85-year-old retiree from Kentucky has filed a lawsuit accusing a group of coin dealers of orchestrating a multi-million dollar fraud scheme that targeted elderly investors. James T. Tanner claims that multiple defendants, including Austin Lloyd, Inc., Austin Coins, Inc., and several individuals associated with the companies, defrauded him through a telemarketing scam selling overpriced precious metal coins and a fraudulent gold mining investment.

The lawsuit, filed in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of New York on Nov. 26, 2024, alleges violations of federal racketeering laws and deceptive business practices under New York state law.

Tanner alleges that the defendants orchestrated a complex fraud scheme disguised as the sale of precious metal coins as investments. He claims he was manipulated into purchasing overpriced coins and investing in a non-existent "gold mine," resulting in financial losses exceeding $1.7 million.

The defendants named in the lawsuit include corporate entities such as Austin Lloyd, Inc., and Austin Coins, Inc., as well as individuals including Patrick J. White, Eric P. Lesak (who used the alias “Mike Todd”), Sean Klein, Christian Foster, Brandon E. Chancey, and Charisma Perry.

The complaint describes how these parties allegedly conspired to defraud Tanner through high-pressure sales tactics and false promises of lucrative returns on coin investments.

Tanner's complaint details how he was initially contacted by Sean Klein and later introduced to Eric Lesak, who operated under the alias “Mike Todd.” They allegedly persuaded him to purchase numerous coins at inflated prices by convincing him they were undervalued investments with high returns. 

Additionally, Tanner was enticed into lending $250,000 for a purported gold mining venture, which turned out to be fraudulent.

Tanner seeks various forms of relief from the court, including actual damages exceeding $1.7 million, treble damages under RICO statutes and New York law for deceptive business practices, and attorney fees and litigation costs.

Representing Tanner are attorneys from an undisclosed firm. Case I.D. 2:24-cv-08219.

Organizations Included in this History


More News

Daily Feed

Sports

Smithtown's Marcus Wertheim Leads Team Australia

Former Smithtown lacrosse standout Marcus Wertheim is dominating on the world stage. The Smithtown alumnus, who currently attends Brown University, led all players at the Super Sixes tournament, delivering an elite performance against international competition.


Sports

Sachem's Coach Mercurio Elected to Lacrosse Board

Congratulations to Sachem Athletic Hall of Famer Rick Mercurio, who was elected to the World Lacrosse Board of Directors during the organization’s 2025 General Assembly. Mercurio fills one of two open Strategic Director positions, marking another significant milestone in his distinguished career in the sport.


Sports

LaFontaine Heads to the Isles Hall

Pat LaFontaine’s plaque has officially been added to the Islanders Hall of Fame wall, placing him among some of the most legendary figures in franchise history. The former star forward was inducted into the Ring of Honor at UBS Arena, becoming the 17th member to receive the prestigious distinction.